SheriaNet for Android — search and read Kenyan case law from your phone, offline.
Join the beta →

AGGREY ARUWA & ANOTHER v NICHOLAS S. AMUTAVI [2007] KEHC 2804 (KLR)

[2007] KEHC 2804 (KLR) High Court of Kenya
Read PDF
Court
High Court of Kenya
Case number
2804
Citation
[2007] KEHC 2804 (KLR)
Decided
25 May 2007
AI Summary Beta Machine-generated — may contain errors. Not legal advice.
TypeCivil AppealPostureAppellants seek stay of execution of judgment in lower court caseCoramR. NAMBUYE
Holding

The court grants a stay of execution pending appeal on certain terms

Facts

Respondent filed an accident claim against appellants in Milimani Commercial Court RMCCC 13969 of 2004. The appellants appealed the judgment, citing issues with the doctrine of subrogation and difficulty in recovering money from a non-party insurance company.

Issues

  1. doctrine of subrogation not pleaded
  2. finding that money be paid to non-party insurance company

Reasoning

The court found that the appellants have an arguable appeal and that substantial loss may result from the judgment. The court granted a stay with conditions to ensure fair treatment of both parties.

Outcome

Stay granted pending appeal

Orders

  • decretal amount to be deposited in court within 60 days
  • respondent to bear costs of application
  • applicant to move with speed to process appeal
  • liberty to apply to either side

Authorities cited

Cases cited (4)
  • KENYA RTS AUTHORITY VERSUS PAUL NJOGU MUNGAI & OTHERS NAI 204/1999(UR 87/93)
  • NYAMODIOCHIENG NYAMOGO AND OTHERS VERSUS KENYA POSTS AND TELECOMMUNICATION NAI 204/1999 (UR 87/93)
  • JAVAN LEWA MUYE VERSUS SHIVA ENTERPRISES LTD AND OTHERS NAI 153/1995(70/95 UR)
  • ICDC VERSUS DABER ENTERPRISES LTD NAI 223/1999(89/99 UR)
Experimental AI summary generated by a language model, not a lawyer. It may contain errors or omissions and must not be relied on for legal decisions — the full judgment below is the authoritative source.
Full judgment 0.1 MB · PDF

Loading judgment…

Cite this case


        
        
      

Share this case