John Boro Waiharo v Republic [2019] KEHC 3560 (KLR)
- Court
- High Court of Kenya
- Case number
- 3560
- Citation
- [2019] KEHC 3560 (KLR)
- Decided
- 17 October 2019
Declare a mistrial, quash the conviction, set aside the sentence of imprisonment for twenty years, and order a retrial by a different magistrate.
Facts
On 9th September 2010, the appellant allegedly committed an act of defilement with a 12-year-old girl named BMM in Gatanga District, Central Province. The appellant was charged with defilement and an alternative charge of indecent act with a child.
Issues
- Non-compliance with Section 200 of the Criminal Procedure Code
- Insufficiency of evidence for penile penetration
- Lack of credibility in prosecution witnesses
- Failure to record reasons for believing the complainant's testimony
- Insufficient evaluation of evidence by the trial magistrate
Reasoning
The court found non-compliance with Section 200 of the Criminal Procedure Code, and the conviction was based on insufficient evidence for penile penetration. The court also noted the trial magistrate's failure to record reasons for believing the complainant's testimony and insufficient evaluation of evidence.
Outcome
Appeal upheld, conviction and sentence quashed
Orders
- Declare a mistrial
- Quash the conviction
- Set aside the sentence of imprisonment for twenty years
- Order a retrial by a different magistrate
Authorities cited
Legislation (2)
- Criminal Procedure Code
- Evidence Act
Cases cited (3)
- Mark Limo Chesire v Republic [2019] eKLR
- Fatehali Manji v Republic [1968] EA 343
- Mwangi v Republic [1983] KLR 522
Loading judgment…